Great food, service and lively atmosphere. Its hard to believe that such a roaring success can exist for 20 years with the seeming limited dollars along Red Arrow Highway. It exceeded all our Chicago-restaurant expectations and was just what we were looking for. An upgrade alternative to William B's in the casino. Great wine list. The chef was thoughtful and creative without being esoteric. Loads of fun at a high top in the bar. We enjoyed some of the rowdy guests celebrating birthdays around us, but the food was the main event. We liked the flash fried brussels sprouts appetizer, grilled romaine Caesar salad, steak with "any seafood", and key lime pie (served either way) .

Dan R.  Yelp Reviews

After coming to Timothy's to dine for years, we hosted our wedding rehearsal dinner there and had an amazing experience. We worked with Starla to set up a menu and accommodate our 50 guest party, and she was great to work with, providing direction on how to best make the dinner work for our party. We were set up in the Woodland Room looking out over their garden, and our guests all commented on the great decor and view.

On the food front, we knew from experience, but our guests really enjoyed the appetizers, especially the calamari with curry sauce and Bang Bang Shrimp. Our steak, chicken, and fish entrees were also fantastic. As the wine was flowing and the meals were served, ace servers Rachel and Christie did an amazing job ensuring everyone was taken care of.

Our guests all complimented us on the food, service, and ambiance - huge thanks to the team at Timothy's for a great rehearsal dinner!.

Matt P.  Yelp Reviews

What an incredible place! This restaurant came highly recommended for us to try while on vacation and it did not disappoint. My husband and I had the crab cakes appetizer and the shrimp au vin. My mouth is still watering from the miso aioli that came with the delicious crab cakes. And the shrimp au vin was absolutely amazing! I tried a few bites from what was passed around at our table and everything I ate was wonderful. Plus, our server was very kind and accommodating. The restaurant itself is beautiful. It has really cool features like the TVs in the floor in the bar area, the beautiful lighting in the entry, and the really pretty fish art piece in the first dining area. It also has a beautiful patio area with gorgeous waterfall feature and lots of greenery. A truly wonderful experience!..

Katie A.  Google Reviews

Highly recommended! Consistently great good with  fun and friendly service. Always an interesting menu with delicious standards and new items with a creative flair. We like the quality and well priced house wine selections. I wish I knew the name of the charming and welcoming hostess - next time I will make a note.  Heather was our server with smart recommendations and a warm smile!

R. G.  Google Reviews

.After spending all day doing the wine trail, Timothy's was actually plan B after our initial choice was not available; the universe works in mysteious ways. The website states: "Trust it to be wonderful." And it was. It was actually spectacular. I had the Wagyu sirloin, and along with the sauce, it was among the best steak I've ever had. My wife had the ribeye. Cooked perfectly, though it was a tad under seasond. Overall, 6 star worthy. The service was at the same level, too. Maya was very knowledgeable and attentive..

Seth Damas  Google Reviews